Friday, January 25, 2008

Circular phenomena

Another curious coincidence: in two days I hear of two different odd natural phenomena, and both of them circular in nature.

One is Snow Doughnuts. It's not really explained how the holes appear.

The other is dolphins and bubble-rings. What the heck are those smoke-ring-like bubble phenomena? How do they appear, how do they stick around, and how to they move through the water like that? It seems the dolphins blow them somehow, and it's clear that they are made from air and nothing else from the way they break up, but beyond that it's puzzling to me.

Well, Wiki has an entry on it. Still too me, it's one of those things that are too weird, like ball lightning.

Bert writes:
Have you seen the movie Pushing Tin? If not, you could spend a good moment watching it. But if you did, you will probably remember the scene where Billy Bob Thornton is swept in the air by the wingtip vortex of a landing jumbo jet. Here is another (very dramatic) illustration of the phenomenon.
It may appear mysterious, but the explanation is really quite simple.

Simply put, in order for air to push upwards (e.g. generate lift) on an aircraft wing, there must exist a very significant difference between the pressure below the wing and the pressure above the wing, the former being of course greater than the latter. How this pressure differential is formed is quite frankly a very complex topic, but thankfully is not necessary for us to understand how this happens.

If you simply picture the pressure differential between the two sides of the wing, you will agree that it is only normal that the high-pressure air from under the wing will tend to travel towards the low-pressure area on top of the wing, by any path available. It does just that around the tip of the wing, and violently so I might add. This is what causes the vortex on the photo above, and nothing else. Simple enough, no? (if not, take the time to picture it in your mind, it really is quite simple)

[open parenthesis]
Wingtip vortices tend to move away from the aircraft at a constant yet surprisingly small speed (a few kph). An opposing wind of equal magnitude can therefore nullify such lateral motion and make a vortex remain stationary (i.e. over the runway) for several minutes. Since these phenomena are usually invisible in clear air, they can pose a serious threat to approaching aircraft. In case you ever wondered, this is why air traffic regulations strictly enforce a minimum delay between two successive landings or takeoffs (the smaller the approaching aircraft, the longer the delay). This of course applies mainly to the vortices created by large aircraft.

It is also interesting to note that, for jumbo jets flying at ~35,000 ft above sea level, the outside ambient temperature is less than -50C. However, the temperature measured at the tip of the wing is near +50C (if memory serves well); that's how violent wing tip turbulence is. This temperature variation is also part of what causes the white condensation trails left by airplanes.
[close parenthesis]

The same type of vortices are also formed in water around moving bodies. They can be observed, for example, around the edges of a paddle. They are also created by dolphins fins, but are usually invisible when completely submerged. It is these vortices that "trap" the ring-shaped air bubbles and makes them appear stationary.

This may seem incredibly complex, but keep in mind that the dolphins, like all underwater dwellers, spend their entire lives surrounded by such phenomena. It is therefore only normal that they should perceive vortices quite precisely. It is however not so obvious (downright staggering, if you ask me) that they are able to develop a sufficient understanding, albeit intuitive, of those vortices to use those in their playful endeavors... wow!

6 comments:

Pascal [P-04referent] said...

Weird lightning? Great balls of fire! Thundering typhoons!

Actually, the circle is a very common shape in Nature.

"Dolphins sometimes create bubble rings on purpose, seemingly for amusement."

So they have fun just like the humans who blow smoke rings, except without the tar and other toxics in tobacco smoke. Where's the mystery?
:-)
Definitely interesting, but nothing to get worried about I reckon. I've read of weirder stuff than ring-shaped bubbles.

Now, "crop circles" in a field, ruining significant areas of one's harvest, THAT's definitely worrying. One needs to react promptly, and make up for the loss by charging the tourists that are sure to come and watch.
One has spoken. ;-)

Anonymous said...

"Phenomena?"

Anonymous said...

The physics of the phenomenon are relatively simple. There are YouTube videos of divers producing rings in apparently the same fashion as smoke rings are blown in air. The stationary rings are simply caught in "fin-tip" vortices, so to speak.

The truly amazing part of it is that dolphins not only observed the rings, but that they have learned to produce them at will, as a means of amusement. This is simply mind-blowing.

And to think that there are still people to deny that dolphins and whales are intelligent beings... Einstein was right, stupidity is infinite.

Pascal [P-04referent] said...

"Einstein was right, stupidity is infinite."

Ergo, it can outdo genius any day!

But I think we're running in circles there...

Anonymous said...

No, Animal, that's "MANAMANA". (sigh)

Pascal [P-04referent] said...

"How this pressure differential is formed is quite frankly a very complex topic"

Not really, honestly. It's related to the physics of fluids flow, and even though the equations (Bernouilli theorem) are a little complicated (high school level), the principle is very simple: "the faster a fluid moves in a circuit, the lower the pressure". When a given circuit has varying sections, in the narrowest ones the linear speed of the fluid increases, and hence its pressure drops. Just take my word for it and the rest becomes very simple.

Air is the fluid that is in relative motion to the plane. Actually it is the plane that's moving, but it makes no difference in the local interactions. The wing profile, in birds as well as airplanes, is more convex on the top side, meaning that the air sliding OVER it has a longer way to travel from the front of the wing to the back in the same amount of time, compared to the air passing UNDER the wing, on the flatter side. A curve between two points is longer than a straight line.
As a result, the air right above the wing travels faster, its pressure decreases relatively to that under the wing, and that difference in pressure is the force which pushes the plane upward and durably lifts it in the air.
The other specificities of the typical wing profile are just for minimizing parasitic turbulences, which would disrupt the regularity of that pressure ratio.

When a plane drops inside a turbulence zone, it's because sudden winds from behind decrease the relative speed of the air flow against the wings. It's just as if the air flow was trying to catch up with the plane. This decreases the pressure differencial, and the airplane drops. If it is too close to the ground, or doesn't reach a zone where this reverse wind ends, sometimes the plane may crash, and you hear about it in the TV news. Or, more often, "airports were closed for safety reasons due to strong winds". Strong enough to compromise the sustentation of the heavier-than-air craft.

One main problem with this pressure difference, is the wing tip. The one place where the two areas of different pressure come in free contact, causing the air to escape laterally toward the top side. Because the wing tip is moving, that imbalance of the system is maintained, and the turbulences are constantly left behind the plane. Their vortex shape is a universal physical curve in nature, you'll find it in the shape of galaxies and solar flares as well as in the microscopic motions of molecules. This tells us that the Universe is fractal in shape.

Every time you notice a wing tip with an odd shape, it's probably a system designed to decrease this loss in sustentation, which can significantly increase fuel consumption. A small, double vertical wing, for instance, becomes an obstacle to top and bottom air simply meeting. In many military jet planes, the delta-shaped wings reduce the actual tip to little more than a point. Eagles, vultures and other ace glider birds have those separated feathers at the end of their wings, resembling fingers: these result in the tip becoming like a group of much smaller wings, aerodynamically speaking, and it not only divides the "parasitic vortex" phenomenon, it also greatly decreases its global scale. Making the glider bird that much more efficient at saving energy in flight. It helps owls be near-totally silent in their night hunts, not even a faint "woosh" to warn the rodents.