I'm just watching
Iron Man on blueray*. It's a good movie, like
Transformers it's both well written and visually gorgeous. And funny. (I'm not much into action movies, but when they are fused nicely with SF and humor, that's a different matter.)
One scene illustrates well the problem with military think: Iron Man goes in and wipes out some terrorists that the marines can't get at. The air force don't know who or what it is doing that, so what do they do? They shoot at him.
Military people and others who love to fight say that they are necessary because the world is full of enemies. But the problem is that shooting is not their
last resort, it's their first instinct. When they face something they don't understand, they shoot.
Another thing the film illustrates well is the principle that you make superior weapons to protect yourself, and then you better make sure they don't "fall into the wrong hands". Only the problem is: quick, mention one single weapon in the history of the world which did not fall into "the wrong hands" sooner or later. Usually sooner.
The Dissonance said...
In the twenty years I spent in the U.S. military from Private to Major we were always taught that killing was the last step in a line of escalation. When the US troops went through those huts in Panama I was never so proud as to see that no civilians were shot even though they popped up at very strange times and suddenly. I don't know how they are trained today, but we certainly never shot first and asked questions later. Not in any unit I was in.Eolake said...
Well, that's very good to hear.
I wonder about stuff like napalm, though. I think it's very hard to bomb or napalm villages without innocents getting hurt.
Also, like most human Minds, the military minds is split: there's the sensible mind, and the mind which for example in 2003 planned and promoted "Operation Shock And Awe", which was simply to bomb the city of Baghdad into rubble, murdering at least tens of thousands of innocent men, women, and children. (In the end it didn't happen. Maybe they promoted it to see what level of sadistic destruction they can get away with without too much of an uproar.)
* I can spell Blue-ray right, but I don't, as a mark of disrespect for a format where the machine takes two minutes to load a disc, and doesn't remember how far it played the disc last time, a huge annoyance for me since I always watch a movie in several chunks. So every time I come back to it, I have to wait several minutes for the machine to boot and load, and then I have to find the point where I played to last.
TTL added:
"In the twenty years I spent in the U.S. military from Private to Major we were always taught that killing was the last step in a line of escalation." Your humor is rather macabre, don't you think? Yes, I can see you were probably "taught" all kinds of things. But look what U.S is actually doing. Over one million iraqis killed. Most of them children. And since U.S. had absolutely no reason to go into Iraq* in the first place you surely must be joking about the "last step of escalation" part. Or perhaps you meant: Last step unless the nation willingly hands over control of their natural resources and lets you freely rape their women and torture the males for funny tourist photos. And lets your build a military base the size of the Vatican on their land. Is that what you meant? *) Same for Panama, Vietnam and every other country the U.S. has attacked since WW2. There have been absolutely no valid reason for any of those wars. In each case U.S. has been the aggressor.